|
Index:
Trial 1: Standard vs. Low Energy Diets
Trial 2: Standard vs. High Energy Diets
Conclusions
Trials 1 & 2
Objectives
- To determine the effectiveness of Rovabio Excel
LC when applied to commercial corn/soybean meal-based diets
fed to broilers
- To determine the above without the confounding of results
with application of the product with post-pelleting equipment
- To evaluate the economic benefit based upon how integrators
evaluate products relative to performance and yield data
- Evaluate this design model to use at other locations/regions/species
Justification
- Limited data on strictly corn/soybean meal animal protein-based
broiler diets fed in the U.S. In addition, many companies
have claimed this but have been unable to show CONSISTENT
results. The industry has thus become leery of claims, but
is still open to discussing new findings
Trial 1: Standard vs. Low-Energy Diets
Trial Design
- Broiler floor pen trial - 48 pens containing 60 Ross x
Ross 308 straight run broilers at a
stocking density of 0.67ft²
- Four Treatments: 2 x 2 Factorial
Energy Level:
1. 1999 Average AgriStats values*
2. As #1 with 30 kcal/lb.
decrease in ME
* Nutrients factored with ME
Enzyme Level:
1. No added Rovabio Excel
2. RovabioTM .181L/ton
Start: April 7, 2000; All birds weighed at 0, 21 and 49
days of age
End: May 26, 2000
|
Energy Equivalency of Diets - Accounting
for the
ME Uplift of Rovabio Excel*
|
| |
|
Starter
|
Grower
|
Finisher
|
| Treatment |
Diet |
Minimum
(ME, KCAL/LB)
|
Minimum
(ME, KCAL/LB)
|
Minimum
(ME, KCAL/LB)
|
| 1 |
STANDARD |
1375
|
1410
|
1445
|
| 2 |
LOW (-30 kcal) |
1345
|
1380
|
1415
|
| 3 "ON-TOP" |
STANDARD & ROVABIO* |
1405
|
1440
|
1475
|
| 4 FORMULATION |
LOW & ROVABIO* |
1375
|
1410
|
1445
|
* ADD 30 KCAL UPLIFT
Results
|
Average Feed Conversion Adjusted
for Mortality and Live
Weights - Adjusted to a Common ValueFC,LW
|
| GROUP |
Feed Conv.
|
Live Weight, LBS.
|
| STANDARD ENERGY |
1.977 ab
|
5.512 ab
|
|
COEFFICIENT OF VARIATION
|
4.38%
|
11.00%
|
| LOW ENERGY |
2.009 b
|
5.288 b
|
|
COEFFICIENT OF VARIATION
|
3.61%
|
9.61%
|
| STANDARD ENERGY+ROVABIO |
1.936 a
|
5.795 a
|
|
COEFFICIENT OF VARIATION
|
3.13%
|
7.33%
|
| LOW ENERGY+ROVABIO |
1.976 ab
|
5.519 ab
|
|
COEFFICIENT OF VARIATION
|
2.81%
|
7.03%
|
FC = Adjusted to 5.797 lb Live Weight
LW = Adjusted to 1.936 Adjusted for Mortality Feed Conversion
|
Average Carcass and Breast Meat
Yield
|
| GROUP |
CARCASS
|
BREAST MEAT
|
| STANDARD ENERGY |
69.47% a
|
24.69% a
|
|
COEFFICIENT OF VARIATION
|
2.55%
|
5.38%
|
| LOW ENERGY |
69.43% a
|
24.82% a
|
|
COEFFICIENT OF VARIATION
|
2.37%
|
4.53%
|
| STANDARD ENERGY+ROVABIO |
69.01% a
|
25.22% a
|
|
COEFFICIENT OF VARIATION
|
2.38%
|
3.66%
|
| LOW ENERGY+ROVABIO |
69.64% a
|
25.44% a
|
|
COEFFICIENT OF VARIATION
|
1.77%
|
5.33%
|
|
Rovabio Excel Advantage Per Bird
"On-Top" Method
|
| GROUP |
Feed Cost/
lb of gain
|
Return/Bird
Less Feed Cost
|
Value of
Breast Meat
|
| STANDARD ENERGY |
$0.1312
|
$0.9163
|
$1.9728
|
| STANDARD ENERGY+ROVABIO |
$0.1297
|
$0.9288
|
$2.0477
|
| Rovabio Excel Advantage |
+$0.0015
|
+$0.0125
|
+$0.0749
|
| |
| LOW ENERGY |
$0.1289
|
$0.9209
|
$1.9664
|
| LOW ENERGY+ROVABIO |
$0.1294
|
$0.9426
|
$2.0582
|
| Rovabio Excel Advantage |
-$0.0005
|
+$0.0217
|
+$0.0918
|
|
Rovabio Excel Advantage Per Bird
Formulation "Up-Lift" Method
|
| GROUP |
Feed Cost/
lb of gain
|
Return/Bird
Less Feed Cost
|
Value of
Breast Meat
|
| STANDARD ENERGY |
$0.1312
|
$0.9163
|
$1.9728
|
| LOW ENERGY+ROVABIO |
$0.1294
|
$0.9426
|
$2.0582
|
| Rovabio Excel Advantage |
+$0.0018
|
+$0.0263
|
+$0.0854
|
Trial 2: Standard vs. High-Energy Diets
Trial Design
- Broiler floor pen trial - 48 pens containing 60 Ross x
Arbor Acre straight run broilers at a stocking density of
0.67ft²
- Four Treatments: 2 x 2 Factorial
Energy Level:
1. 1,375, 1,410 and 1,445 kcal/lb
2. 1,405, 1,440 and 1,475 kcal/lb
Enzyme Level:
1. No added Rovabio Excel
2. Rovabio Excel .181L/ton
NOTE: The energy levels for the Low-Energy Diets in Trial
1 were not used due to having to dilute (alfalfa meal);
i.e., they were not practical to make.
Start: July 17, 2000; All birds weighed at 0, 21,and 49
days of age
End: September 4, 2000
|
Energy Equivalency of Diets - Accounting
for the
ME Uplift of Rovabio Excel*
|
| |
|
Starter
|
Grower
|
Finisher
|
| Treatment |
Diet |
Minimum
(ME, KCAL/LB)
|
Minimum
(ME, KCAL/LB)
|
Minimum
(ME, KCAL/LB)
|
| 1 |
STANDARD |
1375
|
1410
|
1445
|
| 2 |
HIGH (+30 kcal) |
1405
|
1440
|
1475
|
| 3 "ON-TOP" |
STANDARD & ROVABIO* |
1405
|
1440
|
1475
|
| 4 FORMULATION |
HIGH & ROVABIO* |
1435
|
1470
|
1505
|
* ADD 30 KCAL UPLIFT
Results
|
Average Feed Conversion Adjusted
for Mortality and Live
Weights - Adjusted to a Common ValueFC,LW
|
| GROUP |
Feed Conv.
|
Live Weight, LBS.
|
| STANDARD ENERGY |
2.121 c
|
4.730 c
|
|
COEFFICIENT OF VARIATION
|
3.10%
|
9.72%
|
| HIGH ENERGY |
2.049 b
|
5.239 b
|
|
COEFFICIENT OF VARIATION
|
1.71%
|
4.67%
|
| STANDARD ENERGY+ROVABIO |
2.002 a
|
5.566 a
|
|
COEFFICIENT OF VARIATION
|
2.93%
|
7.38%
|
| HIGH ENERGY+ROVABIO |
2.010 ab
|
5.512 ab
|
|
COEFFICIENT OF VARIATION
|
2.79%
|
7.12%
|
FC = Adjusted to 5.614 lb Live Weight
LW = Adjusted to 1.995 Adjusted for Mortality Feed Conversion
|
Average Carcass and Breast Meat
Yield
|
| GROUP |
CARCASS1
|
BREAST MEAT2
|
| STANDARD ENERGY |
70.97% a
|
22.66% b
|
|
COEFFICIENT OF VARIATION
|
1.46%
|
1.28%
|
| HIGH ENERGY |
71.28% a
|
22.59% b
|
|
COEFFICIENT OF VARIATION
|
1.33%
|
1.33%
|
| STANDARD ENERGY+ROVABIO |
71.09% a
|
23.57% a
|
|
COEFFICIENT OF VARIATION
|
1.07%
|
1.72%
|
| HIGH ENERGY+ROVABIO |
71.39% a
|
23.31% a
|
|
COEFFICIENT OF VARIATION
|
1.13%
|
1.65%
|
1 Two males and 2 females per pen
2 Males only
|
Rovabio Excel Advantage Per
Bird
"On-Top" Method
|
| GROUP |
Feed Cost/
lb of gain
|
Return/Bird
Less Feed Cost
|
Value of
Breast Meat
|
| STANDARD ENERGY |
$0.1389
|
$0.8529
|
$1.6968
|
| STANDARD ENERGY+ROVABIO |
$0.1335
|
$0.9191
|
$1.8244
|
| Rovabio Excel Advantage |
+$0.0054
|
+$0.0662
|
+$0.1276
|
|
Previous Trial
|
(+$0.0015)
|
(+$0.0125)
|
(+$0.0749)
|
| |
| HIGH ENERGY |
$0.1373
|
$0.8953
|
$1.7345
|
| HIGH ENERGY+ROVABIO |
$0.1389
|
$0.9307
|
$1.8190
|
| Rovabio Excel Advantage |
-$0.0016
|
+$0.0354
|
+$0.0845
|
|
Previous Trial (Low energy)
|
(-$0.0005)
|
(+$0.0217)
|
(+$0.0918)
|
|
Rovabio Excel Advantage Per
Bird
Formulation "Up-Lift" Method
|
| GROUP |
Feed Cost/
lb of gain
|
Return/Bird
Less Feed Cost
|
Value of
Breast Meat
|
| STANDARD ENERGY+ROVABIO |
$0.1335
|
$0.9191
|
$1.8244
|
| HIGH ENERGY |
$0.1373
|
$0.8953
|
$1.7345
|
| Rovabio Excel Advantage |
+$0.0038
|
+$0.0238
|
+$0.0899
|
|
Previous Trial
|
(+$0.0018)
|
(+$0.0263)
|
(+$0.0854)
|
Conclusions:
Further considerations...
|